What is Money Laundering?

November 5, 2020

By Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

jeremy@texasdefensefirm.com

(972) 369-0577

Money laundering is the safekeeping of illegal proceeds.  People tend to think of it as actually trying to cleanse money by having an elaborate scheme of putting up a fake business front so law enforcement can’t trace illegal proceeds – but in reality it’s much simpler (at least under Texas State Law).

My experience is that rarely is money laundering a stand alone charge.  It is typically either brought along with other – often more serious charges – or it is a charge brought against someone when other charges may be more difficult to prove.

Money Laundering:  Texas vs. Federal Law

Money laundering can be charged in either state or federal court.  State court uses a value ladder to determine the punishment range and the federal sentencing guidelines are also contingent on the amount alleged to be “laundered.”

The federal government has a much more complex definition and categorization of money laundering than Texas does.  You can read the federal statute here.  You can read the state statute here.

Examples of Money Laundering

Example 1:

Let’s say the person is accused of having a business where they advertise widgets on the internet.  People pay online for the widgets, but after they pay – the person just pockets the money and never sends out a widget in return.  It’s obviously theft and/or fraud.  Also the person is committing money laundering by putting the money in his bank account.  You would think the prosecutors would only charge defendant for theft here, and they might.  They also have the option of money laundering too.  Maybe they throw it in for plea bargaining leverage.

Example 2:

Someone is involved in a retail theft ring. They steal from retail stores and re-sell the items.  They take the money they get from the reselling and put it into their bank account.  It’s money laundering even though there are additional steps.

Conspiracies and Party Liability with Money Laundering

Where money laundering can get somewhat gray is in the case of multi-person conspiracies.  The way a conspiracy works under the law – a person doesn’t have to have full knowledge of the entire scheme to be guilty of taking part of the conspiracy.

Tweaking the facts of example #2, let’s say the bank account the money ultimately goes in to is a joint account between spouses – with the other spouse not involved in the ring at all.  This would be an instance where the state or federal government could either charge or threaten that spouse with money laundering – typically in an attempt to get them to spill their guts and cooperate about what they know of the entire illegal operation.

The issue may turn on whether the spouse was willfully ignorant of the scheme or not.  Did they realize the account seemed inflated often for no reason?  Did they check the bank account on a regular basis?  Did the other spouse conceal, hide and do everything possible to control the account?

In any regard – money laundering normally involves a complex factual scenario either in state or federal court.

*Jeremy Rosenthal is board certified in criminal law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization.  He is recognized as a Texas Super Lawyer by Thomson Reuters.

 


White Collar Criminal Defense – State Versus Federal Prosecutions

October 31, 2020

By Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

jeremy@texasdefensefirm.com

(972) 369-0577

“White collar” crime typically refers to allegations about business related wrongdoings – frequently with accounting or other executive level indiscretions.

Both state and federal authorities police white collar cases.

Examples of white collar charges can be:

What is the Difference Between State and Federal Prosecution for White Collar Cases?

Sometimes it’s as simple as jurisdiction.  The federal government has jurisdiction over Medicare fraud and federal income tax evasion.  Other times, the criminal enforcement over-laps and either could prosecute if they wanted though they generally coordinate so as to not waste resources.

Why Does the Federal Government Prosecute Some Cases and Not Others?

The federal government tends to focus more on cases of higher financial value.  They also frequently prosecute cases where there are more potential guilty parties and co-conspirators.  You might see a state level prosecution with 3, 4 or 5 people involved in a white-collar conspiracy.  It’s not uncommon, though, to see the US Attorneys prosecution a crime ring with 20 suspects or more.

Differences in Investigation Resources and Capacity

The federal government is a very well oiled machine in terms of investigation and case work-up on pretty much every level.  The US attorney typically works hand-in-hand with agencies such as the FBI, DEA, ATF, homeland security and any other federal agency you can think of such as the SEC and IRS.

State level investigations can be excellent as well – but there is more of a hit and miss chance.  The state of Texas does have a State Securities prosecution team, for example, as well as the Texas Rangers.  At the same time, a smaller police agency officer or detective with far less training may try to put together a white collar case and not really have the best idea of what they’re doing.  Federal investigators can and often do help out state agencies – but state agencies might not always ask even when they should.

Differences in Trial

It’s far more likely in federal court – if you opt to have a trial – to be on trial with whatever co-defendants have not already plead guilty.  This could mean being on trial at the same time with the same jury as everyone else charged in the same conspiracy.

You can be put on trial with someone else in State Court – but it is less frequent and the rules make it easier for you to split the cases apart.

The rules of trial from State and Federal Court aren’t perfectly and completely aligned, but they are very similar.  The differences are a completely different topic which could probably be the subject of an entire law school class.  The differences, though, are pretty technical and can be somewhat minute.

Differences in White Collar Punishment: State vs. Federal

State level punishment can differ drastically from federal punishment.  Federal punishment tends to be dictated by the federal sentencing guidelines and will ultimately be decided by a judge.  Texas state courts give a defendant the option of having a judge or jury impose sentencing – and the sentencing is encompasses a far broader range of possible jail – and in many instances probation too.

*Jeremy Rosenthal is board certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization.  He has been designated as a Texas Super Lawyer by Thomson Reuters.

 

 


White Collar Crime

September 15, 2010

By Collin County Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

(972) 369-0577

texasdefensefirm.com

“White Collar Crime” refers generally to corporate crimes including but not limited to fraud, bribery, insider trading, embezzlement, computer crimes, money laundering, identity theft and forgery.  White collar allegations can be particularly detail oriented both with the facts and with the law.

What Makes Charges Scary

Having Defended multiple cases — the pattern you sometimes see is the investigators decide you’re a criminal first and then go about putting their case together later.

White collar cases — with the often hundreds if not thousands of documents tend to be like huge mosaics.  Anyone can take a portion of the documents to paint a certain picture which may not reflect how a business or transaction was really conducted.

If you’re charged with a white collar crime you need a lawyer who can show investigators, prosecutors and juries the 40,000 foot view instead of a handful of cherry-picked documents.

Major Differences Between Other Charges

Unlike every-day “street” crimes, “white collar crimes” can be very document-intensive and require experienced counsel that is experienced in document review and analysis.  Prosecutors may take a 1,200 page stack of documents and breeze over them to make sure it fits their theory of the case — but a white collar criminal defense lawyer doesn’t have that luxury.  A white collar crimes lawyer has to understand that the key evidence that can lead to acquittal can be buried on page 1,034 in the third paragraph from the bottom.

Additionally, the prosecution in white collar cases can fall into many traps.  Charging crimes such as embezzlement and misappropriation of fiduciary property is tricky — and some prosecutors, for example, lazily try to prosecute these cases like it was shoplifting from a big-box store.  An experienced white collar defense lawyer can expose and utilize such prosecutorial errors.

If you’re accused of a white-collar crime you should involve counsel immediately.

*Jeremy Rosenthal is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. Nothing in this article is intended to be legal advice.  For any legal advice for any specific situation you should directly consult an attorney.