Probation FAQ’s

March 29, 2010

By Collin County Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

(972) 369-0577

texasdefensefirm.com

Probation (technically called community supervision), is where the Judge suspends all or part of the sentence in a case for a certain period of time.  In the probationary period, the person typically completes community service and other requirements such as classes or drug testing.

A person on probation in Texas must complete and abide by “terms and conditions” of probation.  Typically a person cannot commit an offense against the State of Texas or any other state as a minimum.  Other requirements range from requiring the defendant to report changes in address, changes in employment, and new arrests, if any.

Difference between Deferred and Probation

Deferred adjudication is where you have not been convicted.  Probation is where you have been convicted for the offense.  While on deferred, you must still complete community supervision as if you were on regular probation for most offenses.  The terms can be used interchangeably, but they’re not really identical.

Probation Eligibility

If you’ve never been convicted of a felony in Texas or any other state you are usually eligible for probation. Convicted felons are tricky and it is best to consult a lawyer about your specific situation.  Prosecutors have differing policies against offering probation for certain offenses such as drug trafficking, robbery, and crimes against children.

Can I have Probation Records Expunged?

No.  Expunctions for cases above class C misdemeanors require acquittal or another legal bar to prosecution.  You may be eligible for a petition for non-disclosure, however.

Is there Probation for Federal Offenses?

Yes, but it is likely that if you get probation in Federal Court that you will still serve jail at some point.  There is no parole in Federal prison so almost the only way you can be released from prison without serving all of it is to serve part of it on probation.

Can I be Released from Probation Early?

Yes, you are generally eligible for early release in Texas state courts for probation 1/3 of the way through probation and if  you’ve completed every requirement.  There is no early release for DWI offenses, certain drug offenses, and sex crimes.

Can I do Rehab Instead of Probation for Drug Crimes?

It depends on the case and the willingness of the prosecuting attorney to all an arrangement like this.  More often than not, a prosecutor or Judge may include the rehab as part of probation but not necessarily replacing probation altogether.  This is the type of deal an experienced attorney may help you reach with the prosecutor.

What if I don’t Like my Probation Officer?

Do your best to get along with them even if that means swallowing your pride.  They hold the keys to your jail cell.  In their defense, probation officers have a very difficult job.  The better you get along with them, the more they appreciate you… but they can be extremely damaging to your case if they think you’re a problem.  If they become verbally abusive or play games you may consider involving an attorney though getting a different probation officer can be difficult.

Probation Violations

If you violate probation, your probation officer can cause a probation revocation proceeding (or an adjudication proceeding if you are on deferred) to occur.  You’d be re-arrested and the only issue before the Court is whether you violated your deferred or probation.  If the state proves even one violation more than a preponderance of the evidence, the judge can convict you of the deferred, or revoke your probation.  If this is done, you may be required to serve all or part of the underlying jail sentence.  Often on revocations, however, the judge may extend probation or take some lesser action.

*Jeremy Rosenthal is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. Nothing in this article is intended to be legal advice.  For specific legal advice for any situation, you should consult an attorney.


Top 5 Mistakes When Hiring A Criminal Defense Attorney Countdown — #1

February 17, 2010

By Collin County Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

(972) 369-0577

This week I’m counting down the top 5 mistakes people make in hiring a criminal defense attorney.

#1.  Hiring a lawyer that pleads everyone guilty.

I approach every case looking for a way to win – not why we should lose.  Sometimes the paths to victory are many, sometimes they are wide, and sometimes there is just a sliver of hope.  But the slivers are there if you look hard enough. I consider pleading guilty a last-option in most instances in Texas state courts in Collin and Dallas counties.

This means I set a decent percentage of them for trials or motions to suppress.  But there are lawyers who advise their clients to plead guilty virtually every time.

I rarely question another lawyer’s professional judgment.  And let’s be straight – pleading guilty or not guilty is exclusively the client’s decision.  But a lawyer’s advice typically plays a very heavy part.

I struggle to think of reasons why a particular lawyer simply never puts the State of Texas to task.  Maybe they’re intimidated.  Maybe they lack confidence.  Maybe they’ve made the immature mistake of sitting in judgment on their client if the client used poor judgment or made a mistake.

Whatever the case may be – trial is an important option and a constitutional right.  It should at least be discussed and considered.  Not having that option severely restricts your chances for success.

The cure for this is simple.  When interviewing your lawyer you should ask them how often they take cases to trial?  When was the last time they tried a case?  How many cases like yours have they tried in the past couple of years?

The answers will be revealing.  I’m not suggesting the “tougher” lawyers are better – but you should consider hiring someone that doesn’t take options off the table and who isn’t afraid to pull the trigger and take the state to trial.

*Jeremy Rosenthal is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. Nothing in this article is intended to be legal advice.  For legal advice consult an attorney.


Do You Need a Lawyer for a Drug Case in Texas?

February 11, 2010

By Collin County Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

(972) 369-0577

jeremy@texasdefensefirm.com

Drug cases are very technical in nature and are typically more defendable than you may think.  They’re not hopeless and by just talking with the prosecutor yourself, you’re precluding almost any chance of acquittal.  This is for several reasons.

First is that the evidence must be seized lawfully.  In Texas, Article 38.23 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure holds that unlawfully seized evidence cannot be admitted into evidence.  If the prosecution has no evidence, they lose because they have the burden of proof.  The sands are constantly shifting between what is reasonable police conduct and what is not under the 4th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

If you’re reading this article for your own case, you probably know by now that police can sometimes be highly aggressive, persistent, and sometimes manipulative in their goal of searching your person, car, or home.  When they legally reach too far — and it’s an easy and common mistake for them to make — a judge may throw out all or some of the evidence against you.  This happens where I practice, in Collin County, Texas, all the time.

Also the legal definition of “possession” in the Texas Penal Code under Section 1.07(a)(39) means “actual care custody control or management.”  Merely because you were in the same vehicle or area where drugs were found doesn’t mean the evidence is legally or factually sufficient to demonstrate “possession” and could also mean acquittal from a judge or jury.  And remember — the state has to prove you are guilty.  You have the right to remain silent during the arrest and all through your trial and never have to prove your innocence!

Though the Texas legislature and courts have made recent pushes towards rehabilitation for marijuana cases and other prescription abuses such as hydrocodone or oxycontin, the government’s version of “help” could still mean labeling you a criminal for the rest of your life an subjecting you to treatment which could be inferior to treatment you could get in the outside world.

Having an attorney in a Texas marijuana or other drug case can help you evaluate your legal position in the matter and if necessary, can help mitigate the charges against you.

 

*Jeremy Rosenthal is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. He is a Texas Super Lawyer as designated by Thomson Reuters.  www.texasdefensefirm.com


Should I just talk to the Prosecutor when I go to Court?

February 6, 2010

By Dallas and Collin County Criminal Defense Lawyer Jeremy Rosenthal

(972) 369-0577

jeremy@texasdefensefirm.com

There’s not much in it for you.

The prosecutor may be a nice person.  Most are.  Your criminal record, though, is not as important to them as getting to lunch on time.

Prosecutors are your legal opponent and frankly most have never defended anyone so they don’t understand nuances to keep your record clean.  They don’t understand how to minimize collateral consequences such as professional licensing, immigration, or future enhancement.  Most have never had to crack a book on these issues.  Many will make uninformed representations about your rights and about the effects of your plea.

In fairness to prosecutors, It’s not their job to point out legal and factual weaknesses in their own case which can result in acquittal.  They don’t review a police report critically like a defense attorney would for legal issues, defenses, and inconsistencies.  They see the police report as a checklist and not much more.

Many times people think because they made a mistake or because no one will believe their side of the story – they need to just visit with the prosecutor, take their medicine and get it over with because it’s hopeless and there is no need to spend money on a lawyer.  You may not think it’s a big deal now, but studies have shown criminal records cost people money over the course of their lives.

I have not met a prosecutor that would retaliate against someone for getting a lawyer though I am sure there are some out there.  Most actually appreciate the opportunity to streamline your case.

Talk to a lawyer!

*Jeremy Rosenthal is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization and licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. Nothing in this article is intended to be legal advice.  For legal advice you should consult an attorney.